IllinoisCaseLaw.com

Home of the Criminal Nuggets Podcast.

Any Race Neutral Reason is Sufficient To Beat A Batson Challenge: That’s The Problem

May 25, 2016 By Arthur McGibbons

People v. Shaw, 2016 IL App (4th) 150444 (April). Episode 174 (Duration 4:14)

Trial court properly accepted race neutral reasons for excluding minority jury members.

Facts

Defendant is African American and was on trial for drug charges. The prosecution excluded two African Americans from the jury.

The State said that “when the question came up could you find the defendant guilty, there was a juror that there was a long pause, there was a look, the Court actually had to repeat the question and that’s in the transcript.”

In regards, to the second African American the state recalled that it had initially sought to remove her for cause because she was friends with defendant’s cousins and nieces.

In addition, the State noted her boyfriend had pending cases and was represented by the public defender’s office.

Any Race Neutral Reason

The trial court found that defendant has not shown purposeful discrimination. The Court finds that the prosecutor was credible and that the prosecutor’s demeanor did not show discriminatory intent, but merely showed strategic decisions.

Furthermore, the Court finds that the two juror’s demeanor can be credibly said to have exhibited the basis for the strike attributable to the jury by the prosecutor.

See Also

People v. Williams, 2015 IL App (1st) 131103 (November)

Illinois Trial Procedure

Check out the
Illinois Trial Resource Page
to learn how criminal trials work.

Filed Under: Batson

Where’s Samuel Partida, Jr.?

Samuel Partida, Jr.Samuel Partida, Jr. is now prosecuting criminal law cases in an Illinois county near you. He is, therefore, unavailable to answer questions on this site. Always remember, there is no substitute for steady, persistent attention to the cases.

FREE SPECIAL REPORT
For Illinois Police Officers & Lawyers.

Free Printed Edition
The Ultimate Police Guide To A Legal Car Search…

Illinois Search & Seizure Guide For Police

Catch Up Quickly With
Everything You Missed
In Car Search Law!

Click here to claim your FREE car search guide.

© 2021 · Steady Persistent Attention To The Cases Is Never Wrong · Disclaimer