Kane County Nuggets

Internal education and training for the Kane County State's Attorney's Office.

  • Episodes
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Login

Prosecutors Wrote B’s Next To All The Potential Jurors Who Were African American

June 30, 2016 By Samuel Partida, Jr.

Foster v. Chatman, SCOTUS No. 14–8349. Argued November 2, 2015—Decided May 23, 2016. Episode 189 (Duration 7:29)

Prosecution makes it pretty clear that they struck black jurors because of their race.

Background

In a 7-1 decision written by Roberts (Thomas was the lone dissent). The defense had obtained prosecutor’s files years after he was convicted of strangling and raping a 79 year old victim.

The files had hand written “B”s in front of all the black jurors.

Batson Challenge

Ultimately, the Court found that, while all of the five potential black jurors had been kept off the jury for racial reasons, the proof was clear at least as to two of those jurors that there was no reason but race for excluding them.

“Two peremptory strikes on the basis of race are two more than the Constitution allows,” Roberts wrote.

Illinois Trial Procedure

Check out the
Illinois Trial Resource Page
to learn how criminal trials work.

Non Race Reasons

The prosecution had an array of excuses for striking these two jury members, including:

  • she had a job working with disadvantaged youth
  • she kept looking at the ground
  • she gave short answers
  • she appeared nervous
  • she was too young
  • she misrepresented her familiarity with the location of the crime
  • she failed to disclose her cousin was arrested on a drug charge
  • she was divorced
  • she had two children and two jobs
  • the defense asked her few questions and
  • she did not ask to be excused from jury service.

Many other jurors accepted by prosecutors had the same attributes as that juror and the second juror whose elimination was at issue.

The State tried to argue that the markings in their file were they because they wanted to be careful and mindful of a Batson issue, but Roberts did not buy that for a second.

Instead, he noted that the argument was made for the first time in the U.S. Supreme Court and it “reeks of afterthought.”

Conclusion

The sad thing here is that 4 of the black stricken members were found to be “justified” ie had valid race neutral reasons and this case really suggests the facts have to be way out there before a judge is likely to find that a Batson violation has indeed occurred.

Filed Under: Batson, SCOTUS

Where’s Sammy P?

Samuel Partida, Jr.Samuel Partida, Jr. is now an Assistant State's Attorney in Kane County. Finding the time for the cases is never easy, and he still believes that there is no substitute for steady, persistent attention to the cases.

FREE SPECIAL REPORT
For Illinois Police Officers & Lawyers.

Free Printed Edition
The Ultimate Police Guide To A Legal Car Search…

Illinois Search & Seizure Guide For Police

Catch Up Quickly With
Everything You Missed
In Car Search Law!

Click here to claim your FREE car search guide.

Categories

  • Accountability
  • Aggravated Battery
  • Appeal
  • Bail
  • Battery
  • Burglary
  • Charges
  • Confession
    • Attenuation
    • Miranda
    • Voluntary
  • Conflict Of Interest
  • Constitutional
  • Contempt Of Court
  • Criminal Possession
  • Discovery
  • Dismissal
  • Disorderly Conduct
  • Double Jeopardy
  • DUI
    • Actual Physical Control
    • Blood
    • DRE
    • Field Sobriety Tests
    • Proximate Cause
    • Suspension
  • Evidence
    • 115-10
    • Accomplice Testimony
    • DNA
    • Expert
    • Eyewitness
    • Hearsay
    • Opinion
    • Other Crimes
    • Over Hear
    • Prior Consistent Statement
    • Privilege
    • Silent Witness
    • Surveillance Privilege
  • Expungement
  • Felony Murder
  • Fitness For Trial
  • Grand Jury
  • Guilty Plea
  • Gun Crimes
    • Armed Habitual Criminal
    • Armed Violence
    • Reckless Discharge
    • UUW
  • Immigration
  • Indictment
  • Ineffective Assistance
    • Krankel Hearing
  • Joinder
  • Judicial Bias
  • Jury Instructions
  • Juvenile Justice
  • Lesser-Included
  • Mental State
    • Knowing
    • Recklessness
    • Sexual Gratification
  • Notice Requirement
  • Obstructing Justice
  • Postconviction Petition
  • Pre-Trial Detention
  • Procedure
  • Professional Responsibility
    • Conflict Of Interest
  • Prosecutorial Misconduct
  • Resisting Arrest
  • SCOTUS
  • Search & Seizure
    • Anonymous Tip
    • Community Care Taking
    • Consent To Search
    • Drug Dog
    • Exigent Circumstances
    • Good Faith Exception
    • Mistake of Law
    • Pat Down
    • Plain View
    • Probable Cause
    • Reasonable Suspicion
    • Search Incident To Arrest
    • Strip Search
    • Traffic Stop
    • Warrant
  • Second Degree Murder
  • Sentencing
    • Aggravation
    • Consecutive
    • Credit For Time Served
    • Dangerous Weapon
    • Enhancement
    • Extended Term
    • Fines & Fees
    • Forcible Felony
    • Gun Add-On
    • Life Sentence
    • Mandatory X
    • Merging Counts
    • Mitigation
    • Probation
    • Restitution
  • Sex Case
    • Child Porn
    • Grooming
    • SORA
  • Speedy Trial
  • Statute of Limitations
  • Structural Error
  • Threatening A Public Official
  • Trial
    • Affirmative Defense
    • Batson
    • Closing Argument
    • Confrontation
    • Immunity
    • Impeachment
    • Insanity Defense
    • Jury
    • Necessity Defense
    • Opening Statement
    • Pretrial Publicity
    • Self Defense
    • Stipulation
  • Vehicular Hijacking
  • Warrant

Tags

Car Search Cell Phone Collective Knowledge constructive possession Corpus Delicti Cumulative Error Defaced Firearm Domestic Violence Drug Induced Homicide Drugs Enhancement Entrapment Excited Utterance Expert Force Forfeiture by Wrongdoing Gang Evidence Gun Add-On Illinois Supreme Court Inventory Search Investigative Alert Jury Instructions Lynch Material Mistrial Nonconsensual Dissemination Odor of Cannabis One Act-One Crime Passenger Polling Jury PowerPoint Probable Cause Public Trial Retrograde Extrapolation Single Punch Social Media SOJ Stipulated Bench Trial Structural Error Sufficiency of the Evidence Traffic Stop Trespass Vehicular Invasion Video Voluntary Intoxication Warrant

Copyright © 2025 ● Disclaimer