IllinoisCaseLaw.com

Illinois Criminal Law Podcast

Drug Dog There In A Flash…

August 29, 2015 By Samuel Partida, Jr.

What happens when this drug dog makes it to the scene of a traffic stop in a flash? The case involves the discovery of 900 grams of heroin. 

See People v. Reedy, 2015 IL App (3d) 130955 (08/26/2015).
Drug Dog There In A Flash | People v. Reedy, 2015 IL App (2d) 130955


Subscribe: iTunes | Android | RSS

This is a very close case.

The trial judge granted the state's motion to suppress evidence. The appellate court abruptly reversed.  

Facts

The car is seen crossing the solid line, twice.

The line crossing happens while on the car is on the entrance ramp to the highway. For one of the crossings, the tire was over the line for 4 to 5 seconds.

Defendant only gets a warning but not before a drug dog responds to the scene and alerts.

Holding

The trial court granted the Defendant's motion to quash and suppress. The case actually involves two defendant's. With that much contraband involved, the passenger also gets charged.

Appellate court abruptly reverses.

Analysis

The reviewing court said that Defendant did not violate the improper lane usage statute, which is applicable only to roadways “divided into 2 or more clearly marked lanes for traffic.” 625 ILCS 5/11-709.

In any event, the appellate court was sure Defendant violated the statute prohibiting driving on the shoulder.  625 ILCS 5/11-709.1(a).

The reviewing court noted that the dog got there almost immediately after the stop. Further, the officer was in the process of writing a warning ticket when the dog alerted. No evidence exists that the drug questioning in any way extended the time of the stop. The entire traffic stop here lasted less than 10 minutes, and this was not a case where the officers stalled in order for a narcotics canine to arrive or to otherwise develop probable cause.

Conclusion

No doubt, in almost all future litigation involving a drug sniffing dog in an Illinois courtroom this case will be in the back pocket of the prosecution.

The defense will still harp and rely heavily on United States v. Rodriguez. 

For more information on challenging drug dogs in court, see my resource page on drug dogs.

Filed Under: Podcast, Search & Seizure

 

Are You Ready To Earn CLE While You Employ A System That Allows You To Consistently Outmatch & Outgun Your Opposition?

If you have 10 minutes a day (sometimes less), a phone, and know how to push play then this may be for you.

Learn More

Click Here To Learn More.

Comments

  1. PM says

    August 31, 2015 at 12:15 pm

    People v. Pulling is also an interesting case you may want to take a look at. I’ll get you the citation from the trial court on a recent case in Henry County that resulted in the suppression of about 1.2 million dollars of meth/heroin that will be going up on appeal shortly that is based on the Rodriguez dog sniff and has that component of timeliness of the dog arriving on scene as well.

    As a defense attorney, I hate the idea that the dog is just showing up and then walked around while someone is waiting for a citation and there’s no indicia of any contraband/illegal activity that would lead to a further investigation but for the dog alerting. It’s obviously not a home but it seems weird to think that it would be ok to just have every officer be a k9 operator and every car gets a dog sniff.

Everything you missed in
Search & Seizure. Includes the important cases. 
It's all there.

Get It Now!

Click Here For Free Special Edition.

Blogger, Podcaster and Now Author…

Learn More Now
Available on iTunes = subscribe on iTunes Available on Google Podcasts Subscribe on Android subscribe to rss feed

FREE Ethics CLE For Illinois Lawyers

Free Ethics CLE For Illinois Lawyers

In this one hour course on professionalism you’ll discover how busy criminal law attorneys find the time to kill it in court. Register below to get instant access to this free ethics CLE.

Listen Now!

Criminal Nuggets Podcast with Samuel Partida, Jr. | a criminal law podcast

Premium Nuggets Podcast | A subscription legal service for Illinois criminal law attorneys

free illinois criminal law webinars and courses

Free Legal Resource For Illinois Attorneys

Free Legal Resource For Illinois Attorneys

Download My Most Popular Case Lists

I've been gathering the cases & one line summaries of the most important criminal law topics.

Get The Cases

Are You Ready To Consistently Outmatch & Outgun Your Criminal Litigation Opposition?

Samuel Partida, Jr. Case Law NinjaHow do you get a judge to do what you want and dominate your courtroom?

Show Me The Secret Now

 

Procedure

Search & Seizure

Evidence

Defenses

Sentencing

Tags

Appeal Attenuation Batson Confession Conflict Of Interest Confrontation Consent Constitutional Discovery Dismissal Double Jeopardy Drug Dog Expert Expungement Extended Term Eyewitness Gun Add-On Hearsay Impeachment Indictment Ineffective Assistance Instructions Jury Juvenile Lesser-Included Life Sentence Mental State Mitigation Notice Other Crimes Postconviction Petition Prior Inconsistent Statement Probable Cause Probation Prosecutorial Misconduct Reasonable Doubt Reasonable Suspicion SCOTUS Speedy Trial Sufficiency of the Evidence Suspended License Traffic Stop UUW Warrant Witness
  • About
  • Free Podcast
  • Resources
  • Login

© 2019 Copyright · Illinois Crimes Index · Illinois Sentencing Index · Disclaimer