IllinoisCaseLaw.com

Home of the Criminal Nuggets Podcast.

Affirmed: Can’t Bring A Drug Dog To Your Front Door For Some Sniffer Action

March 29, 2016 By Arthur McGibbons

People v. Burns, 2016 IL 118973 (March). Episode 154 (Duration 4:58)

The “no-nights visits” rule is affirmed, can’t bring the sniffer dog to your front step for a little sniff action.

Facts

After receiving a tip that Defendant is selling wee from her apartment, the police bring a dog to her apartment door.

The dog alerts to the presence of contraband. The police then go get a warrant.

Issue

Which begs the question: does the warrantless use of a drug-detection dog at an apartment door, located within a locked apartment building, in the middle of the night, violate defendant’s fourth amendment rights?

SCOTUS Case

The elephant in the room here is Florida v. Jardines, 569 U.S. ___, 133 S. Ct. 1409 (2013).

The State argued that the officers conducted a dog sniff on the landing outside of defendant’s apartment door and that the landing was not part of the defendant’s cartilage under the “property-based” analysis announced in Jardines.

Defendant counters that under Jardines, a search warrant is required to conduct a dog-sniff search at the entrance to a home. Indeed, the problem in Jardines, according to Scalia, was that the cops intruded physically on defendant’s property in order to conduct a search.

Holding

However, the Illinois Supreme Court was not persuaded by this argument.

All the relevant factors pointed to the conclusion that this apartment stoop was part of the cartilage of Defendant’s home.

These factors being: (1) “the proximity of the area claimed to be cartilage to the home”; (2) “whether the area is included within an enclosure surrounding the home”; (3) “the nature of the uses to which the area is put”; and (4) “the steps taken by the resident to protect the area from observation by people passing by.” Dunn, 480 U.S. at 301.

This intrusion onto her locked front stoop at 3:20 am was unconstitutional.

See also the Drug Dog Resource Page.

Filed Under: Drug Dog, Police

Where’s Samuel Partida, Jr.?

Samuel Partida, Jr.Samuel Partida, Jr. is now prosecuting criminal law cases in an Illinois county near you. He is, therefore, unavailable to answer questions on this site. Always remember, there is no substitute for steady, persistent attention to the cases.

FREE SPECIAL REPORT
For Illinois Police Officers & Lawyers.

Free Printed Edition
The Ultimate Police Guide To A Legal Car Search…

Illinois Search & Seizure Guide For Police

Catch Up Quickly With
Everything You Missed
In Car Search Law!

Click here to claim your FREE car search guide.

© 2021 · Steady Persistent Attention To The Cases Is Never Wrong · Disclaimer