IllinoisCaseLaw.com

Home of the Criminal Nuggets Podcast.

Why Police Drug Dog Discovery Should Include Veterinarian Records

January 23, 2014 By Arthur McGibbons

Recently, I discussed police dog discovery. I presented that topic as a way to gather the tools necessary to challenge the reliability of a drug dog sniff.

Maybe Challenging the Reliability of a Drug Dog Won’t Be So Easy

A recent Illinois criminal case on a police dog sniff case suggests it is going to be harder to challenge the reliability of a police dog after all. However, I still want to emphasise that it is not all bad news.

In this podcast episode, I discuss the case of People v. Litwhiler.

The case presented a situation with factors that should have diminished the reliability of the police dog in that case. First of all, the dog “detected” illegal mushrooms. Yet, the dog had no training in the detection of mushrooms!

Personally, I don’t understand how this fact did not play a bigger role in the case. This detail is only mentioned in passing. It is not discussed in an analytically way.

Second, the police dog died four months after the search in that case. Again, this is  a detail that is only mentioned in passing. It seems the fact that the dog may have had significant health problems was completely undisclosed to the defense.

The troubling aspects of the decision is that these factors, although noted by the appellate court, essentially played no role in its assessment of the dog’s reliability.

Police Dog Narcotics Training is Not the Whole Story

police dog case law summaryThe court appeared to rely on only one factor determine the dog’s reliability. The court relied 100% on the mere fact that the dog had undergone narcotic detection training. The court relied on nothing else.

It is our job to remind the court that police dog narcotics training is not the whole story.

The case does appear to confirm the defense bar’s concern that it is going to be impossible to challenge the reliability of a police drug dog in court.

I am still holding out for optimism. Thorough police dog discovery should not be abandoned.

In this podcast episode, I suggest that thorough discovery on the dog and the dog handler could provide a pathway to challenge the reliability of the drug dog in court.

Police Dog Discovery Must Include Veterinarian Records

Police dog medical records have to be included in any doggie criminal discovery that the defense is demanding.

In my original article on police dog discovery, I did not include a specific request for doggie medical records. Therefore, the first paragraph of that discovery motion should be amended by the addition of the following lettered paragraph.police dog discovery dog veternarian records

any and all veterinarian and or medical records pertaining to the health and medical condition of Underdog (or said canine)

This new front on the Fourth Amendment battle field is not encouraging. The defense bar must do its best to hold-up the line and prevent what appears to be rampant, unquestioned acceptance of police dog reliability.

There will only be more and more of these police dog cases to come. Good luck out there!

For more information, jump over to my resource page on police drug dogs.

Filed Under: Discovery, Drug Dog

Where’s Samuel Partida, Jr.?

Samuel Partida, Jr.Samuel Partida, Jr. is now prosecuting criminal law cases in an Illinois county near you. He is, therefore, unavailable to answer questions on this site. Always remember, there is no substitute for steady, persistent attention to the cases.

FREE SPECIAL REPORT
For Illinois Police Officers & Lawyers.

Free Printed Edition
The Ultimate Police Guide To A Legal Car Search…

Illinois Search & Seizure Guide For Police

Catch Up Quickly With
Everything You Missed
In Car Search Law!

Click here to claim your FREE car search guide.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

© 2021 · Steady Persistent Attention To The Cases Is Never Wrong · Disclaimer